Low-Quality AI-Generated Ebooks Have Made Their Way Into Public Libraries

Libraries have long been cherished as sanctuaries where individuals can freely explore knowledge without the expectation of spending money.

As Linda Stack-Nelson, a professional in the publishing industry, currently serving as the Production Director at a nonprofit publishing house and literary arts organization, once stated, "Libraries are the last place in every town and city that people can simply exist."

However, recent developments of generative AI tools, powered by Large Language Models that have been publicly available, anyone can create a compelling content, blog posts, and even books.

The internet is literally littered with them, and there is no way of stopping them.

And here, libraries are now becoming a place for them as well.

Public library
Jakarta Library located in Cikini in Jakarta, Indonesia.

Public libraries are encountering a surge of low-quality, seemingly AI-generated books infiltrating their digital collections.

Libraries can use a number of platforms to manage and distribute ebooks.

These platforms allow librarians to curate their collections by selecting specific titles from its extensive catalog, enabling them to control the quality and relevance of available materials. Others require libraries to subscribe to its entire catalog, charging them each time a patron borrows an item.

The influx of AI-generated ebooks however, makes it difficult for anyone to really filter what's good and what's not, and as a result of this, the platforms are making it difficult for librarians to search for specific topics.

And inadvertently, librarians would access subpar content.

Not only that the low-quality ebooks would provide no significant addition to the libraries' collection, many of them are even attributed to authors who have no online presence.

Many of them even use AI-generated profile photo.

It's worth noting that many of the ebooks do include a disclaimer that says the author and publisher "are not experts in the discussed topics," and that they don't include any dangerous information, but having AI-generated information is diminishing the credibility of public libraries.

ChatGPT
LLMs like OpenAI's ChatGPT can help anyone author a book. But the quality of the book is still questionable.

Public libraries are often considered lending libraries, and that they are accessible by the general public. Because of this, despite with the internet being accessible to anyone, public libraries remain viral for education, culture, and community engagement.

These institutions range from expansive national facilities to local community libraries, each contributing uniquely to a nation's literacy and learning.

But now, this influx of AI-generated content not only diminishes the quality of available resources but also places additional strain on library budgets and staff.

Many public libraries are already having librarians overburdened by their job and now, they have to also sift through an overwhelming volume of materials to discern human-authored content from AI-generated works.

Librarians must now navigate the complex task of identifying and filtering out these low-quality materials to maintain the integrity of their collections and ensure patrons receive accurate, reliable information.

As the prevalence of AI-generated content continues to rise, libraries and their patrons must remain vigilant, advocating for transparency and quality in the materials they provide and consume.